I've been tasked with producing a few dozen sugar cookies for a friend's upcoming baby shower. These cookies need to be 1) shaped like fleur de lis and 2) Mardis Gras purple and/or green. So I went on an adventure in sugar cookies this weekend in search of THE perfect sugar cookie. I've just washed down the last round of testing with a tall glass of milk, and here's the data.
1) "The Best Rolled Sugar Cookies" (allrecipes.com )
With over 5,000 reviewers averaging 4.5 stars, I went for this one first, thinking it would be the one.
The take: Basic ingredients, boasts easy prep and roll-out.
The dough: Kinda bland, made me wish I'd added a teeny bit of salt since the recipe includes none and I cook with unsalted butter. (And I usually cut the salt in every recipe by 50% or more, so I'm used to the absence of overtly salty flavor.)
The roll-out: True to the contributor's word, the dough rolled out beautifully. No cracking, held its shape when cut.
The finished product: Kinda bland as expected based on the dough. And just a little tough. Totally edible, but not the chewy deliciousness I was anticipating based on all those rave reviews.
2) Best-loved Sugar Cookies (Better Homes and Gardens)
When all else fails, I go back to my faithful red and white companion, which Mom gave me when I moved away to college.
The take: Uses half butter and half shortening, bake longer at a lower temp
The dough: Delish. I wanted just to sit with a spoon and eat the whole bowl.
The roll-out: Easy. No cracking or tearing. Firm enough to be cut and handled without warping my hearts but not hard.
The finished product: Very sweet and pretty flavorful for an unadorned sugar cookie. But the dough spread A LOT in the oven (chilled as directed after mixing, rolled/cut quickly and then straight in the oven), which resulted it pretty thin cookies with a lot of exterior crunch. Might work better if baked at higher temp for shorter time like the other recipes.
3) Sugar Cookies (Real Simple)
I've not had the best luck with Real Simple recipes, but I was looking for something different from the others I'd tried.
The take: High butter to sugar ratio.
The dough: So yummy. You can tell they're super buttery. Nice smooth texture.
The roll-out: Ug, rough. The dough went from chilled and firm to warm and smooshy really fast with all that butter. Made my little hearts lop-sided.
The finished product: Very buttery as expected, crunchy on the edge but still soft and crumbly in the middle. Not quite the chewiness I usually like in a cookie but appropriately sturdy for decorating.
4) Sugar Cookies (Southern Living)
Southern Living is pretty much the gold standard for anything involving butter and/or sugar. And don't tell me, "No, Paula Deen is." I didn't think of that until just now and don't want to make any more sugar cookies today.
The take: Lots of extra ingredients including lemon juice and vegetable oil.
The dough: Average. Relatively wet, required more time in the fridge to firm up than the others.
The roll-out: The easiest of all. The dough was nicely pliable, rolled out evenly with minimal fuss. Didn't require nearly as much flour as I expected to prevent sticking.
The finished product: More flavorful than #1, much softer than #2, less crunch than #3. But did spread a bit; the hearts were still recognizable but a bit too round. The most similar to what I remember making with Mom as a kid.
 |
Top left, Real Simple. Top right, Southern Living.
Bottom left, allrecipes.com. Bottom left, BHG |
The bottom line... I'll probably go with the Real Simple version and do plenty of chilling between each step since maintaining shape when baked and durability for decorating and transportation are my priorities. However, if I were to do a cookie cake, I'd likely choose BHG since the spreading wouldn't be an issue, and I like just a bit of crunchy outside on thick pan cookies. For drop cookies with buttercream (my
favorite), I'd do Southern Living with my mom's buttercream.
Later this week will be adventures in coloring and pouring royal icing. Let's hope my patients don't mind purple and green fingers.